David Kirby


My Heart Belongs to Halifax


Why I Love Curtis Sittenfeld

                    Everybody will laugh at you if you bring that holiday standby
called “ambrosia salad” to a potluck, but they’ll gobble it down
anyway. Recipes differ, though it’s pretty much a cup each of five things:
mandarin orange slices, pineapple chunks, sweetened coconut flakes,
sour cream, and marshmallows. “Haw, haw!” they’ll say.
“Look what Meemaw brought! Somebody hand me a bowl.”

Don’t believe me? Look up the recipe: actual online comments include
“it looks nasty but it’s really tasty,” “you would have thought
I brought barbecued babies from the looks I got but I didn't
take home any leftovers,” “that’s the stuff I threw up in
a pool twenty years ago,” “I’m getting the sense from these posts
that the word ‘salad’ is a vaguely defined term for many Americans,”

“sometimes I joke about the British eating as though there are still
German planes overhead but then I see ambrosia salad and feel like
the biggest hypocrite in the world,” “if you mix the whipped cream
in with the fruit juices then it doesn't look like vomit,” “served
at every potluck I’ve ever attended where there are Mormons,”
“I wonder why Americans eat as if they have free health care,”

“my mother-in-law called it Idiot Salad but never took home
any leftovers,” “my ex-mother-in-law made this one year
and it was actually pretty good.” Apparently there’s no litmus test
for ambrosia salad. Actually there are very few litmus tests
for anything except litmus: think Taylor Swift vs. death metal,
Jane Austen vs. Hemingway, The Godfather vs. Goodfellas.

During movie shoots, Mel Brooks would hand out handkerchiefs
to the cast and crew to stick in their mouths if they were going
to laugh when a funny scene was being filmed, and he knew
the scenes were funny when he turned around in the director's chair
and saw a sea of white handkerchiefs. That’s why I love
novelist Curtis Sittenfeld, who was once asked what her audience was

and replies that there’s this HBO show called Somebody, Somewhere
starring a plus-sized actress who is having a conversation with
the actress playing her petite sister about the so-called pencil test
in which a woman puts a pencil under her breast, and if it falls out,
that means she has perky breasts, but then the plus-sized actress
picks up this big bottle of salad dressing and wedges it under one

of her enormous boobs. “That’s the tone of the storytelling I want
to do,” Curtis Sittenfeld says. “It’s not the person with the pencil falling out,
it’s the one who puts the bottle of salad dressing under one of her
enormous boobs, and it stays there.” Ha, ha—you’re not the only one
who feels that way, Curtis Sittenfeld! Later in the interview, Curtis
Sittenfeld says, “Isn’t it so weird and undignified to be a person?”